Benutzer Diskussion:Multichill/Denkmal Österreich without ID

Soweit ich momentan sehe, haben alle diese Bilder eine korrekt formatierte ID in der Bildbeschreibung. Irgendwetwas schient hier nicht richtig zu funktionieren. -- Clemens 19:20, 2. Sep. 2012 (CEST)

Hier sind wieder eine Menge falsch positive. Außerdem tauchen hier auch Dummybildchen auf - dass die keine ID haben entspricht ja eigentlich ihrem Sinn und Zweck... -- Clemens 15:06, 13. Okt. 2018 (CEST)

@Multichill: as it is now, it does not make much sense.

• you're using a non-existing template
• there is a lot of false positives (all?)
• dummy images are listed, but will never get an id

best --Herzi Pinki (Diskussion) 17:16, 29. Nov. 2018 (CET)

@Herzi Pinki: thanks for pinging me. I think this is the first time I noticed this talk page. I'm not super involved with ErfgoedBot, but I can probably help you:

• Do you have a better page location to publish this? I would like to get it out of my user space. Please just a new name and no move yet, configuration needs to be updated
• What is the non-existing template? Currently it suggests Commons:Template:Denkmalgeschütztes Objekt Österreich and that seems to be correct.
• Did you already try null edits on the false positives?
• I'm not sure if we support filtering out dummy images

For completeness sake, the configuration is at https://github.com/wikimedia/labs-tools-heritage/blob/master/erfgoedbot/monuments_config/at_de.json . If anything changes on the wiki (renames of categories/templates/field names) without updating the configuration, all sorts of weird things start to happen. Multichill (Diskussion) 18:34, 29. Nov. 2018 (CET)

@Multichill:

• I do not have a problem with the location, but if you want a better location I would propose Portal:Österreich/Denkmallisten/Denkmal Österreich without ID and even better Portal:Österreich/Denkmallisten/Denkmalbilder Österreich without ID
• Commons:Template:Denkmalgeschütztes Objekt Österreich is on commons, but does not exist on de:WP. We do even not have a simple way to link to specific IDs, neither on Commons nor on de:WP. Except via AleXww's tool. If you have the name of the list at hand, than you can use {{BDA Objekt Ref}} here to link to the de:WP. Commons:Template:Denkmalgeschütztes Objekt Österreich does not link back to the entry in the de:WP Denkmalliste, except via an unsharp search.
• images do not change that often. Thus doing nulledits will not change the version your script will see. e.g. Liste der denkmalgeschützten Objekte in Möggers was changed about one year ago, and File:Pfarrkirche Möggers 1.jpg was changed 5 years ago. But it is listed on the front side. I fear, the problem should be fixed in your scripts. If you look at the version history,
• Dummies did not show up before.

best --Herzi Pinki (Diskussion) 19:34, 29. Nov. 2018 (CET)